The Kramdens show up at the window, causing the Harper quads to freak out and accidentally turn off the simulator. After realizing that Faith, Hope and Susan are falling in love with Joey as well, the boys lie to the girls that Joey is dating Dawn. The quads are caught red-handed trying to cover it up. Principal Tarian is disappointed, but Ricky manages to convince him that it was all part of the plan. Nicky, Dicky, and Dawn then feel bad for him and climb to the top of the stairs to rap alongside him.
The quads stop the tape after Tom and Anne agree that Valentine's Day is ruined forever. Anne tells them that the triangle of romance is ridiculous and they shouldn't try to force it. However, when Dawn lets Squishy out into the backyard through the doggy door, things go wrong when Squishy digs out and escapes. The other children later attempt to be different superheroes, but the children still prefer Nicky. Syd then begins to realize the error of her ways and her and the quads truly bond for the first time. When the skates get accidentally burned after the fight, Tom and Anne agree to put a theme that combines all the ideas from their kids.
The art contest judges are impressed by the sculptures only to realize that they are actual children and Jackie gets disqualified. While Anne's focus is on the overnight bag, Ricky asks Nicky to put the thermometer into his mouth for a normal temperature reading who then asks Dicky to do so because he doesn't want to get sick. Dicky and Ricky start using the Squishy Paws excuse to get what they want out of sympathy. Nicky keeps adjusting his alarm clocks until he gets kicked out of the boys' bedroom. They discover that the new neighbors have a child named Syd and begin plotting on how to use her for their own needs.
She also has a history at other schools, and it's the reason why her and her family moved, and if she messes up again, she'll be sent to boarding school. Ricky freaks out and unleashes bees at the space station. At the club, Madison makes fun of Dawn and Mae for not being members. To attract people to the charity and to impress the girls, Nicky, Ricky and Dicky get Joey to perform, but Dawn is worried that Joey's presence might expose their secret relationship. The cops take Ricky's siblings away, to jail. Madison checks it out and is impressed.
Back at the house, the quads are resting miserably alongside Anne, Tom, and Squishy Paws who had also become sick, though Tom couldn't exactly figure out how Squishy Paws became sick. Mae apologizes for calling Dawn pushy and Dawn agrees that she can be pushy. While the Harper quads are hanging at Tom's Get Sporty when Madison arrives. After overpowering her brothers and gaining entry into the simulator, she agrees that it was totally worth it. Madison acknowledges that there might be a lesson for her but says that she doesn't care. The Gourmet Guy gives it a bad review.
They conclude that she's also becoming a werewolf and lock her up with Dicky. It's later discovered at Syd's house that Syd and her family were told to stay away from the Harper family due to the quads' bad reputation, though Syd doesn't personally care about their alleged bad reputation, but because she has a bad side as well, she thinks it's best not to make friends with the quads. Anne later shows up to find the house a mess, but is not upset with Tom or the children because she was expecting a lot worse. To create drama for the show, the quads pressure Mae into uninviting someone from her birthday party. They plan to sneak out, but fall into a trash bin. They even conduct a research which reveals that their parents are the problem. Mae confronts them for not even trying.
However, it's not enough, but Dicky has bad breath and belches to lure the dog over and lick everybody. Later, they brew up a cure and put it in Tom and Anne's shoes. At first his plan works, but Dawn later finds out about his scheme and sets out to expose the truth. She gets help from her brothers to delete the voicemail before Miles hears it. Her brothers refuse to help at first, but change their mind after seeing Faith, Hope and Susan participating in the charity. When the game ends close to a tie, Ricky feels that they didn't deserve the win and reveals that Madison cheated. Archived from on October 27, 2014.
When Nicky, Ricky, and Dicky decide that Dawn is a bad luck charm, Mae gets Science Bob to help out. Dawn helps Dicky realize that they're just going through puberty. Moses March 14, 2015 2015-03-14 119 1. Mae and Miles become furious that Dawn was trying to separate them, so Dawn apologizes and Mae promises to spend more time with her. However, Principal Tarian gives Natlee a list of safe approved stunts to choose from, but the quads go against the rest of the committee to reject the list. So, Dawn leads her brothers to stand up for ice-dancers. However, during the next Buffa-Lowdown, Dawn realizes that Avery has a crush on Nicky, so she tries to stop Ricky from embarrassing himself, but things go awry.
The War Pigs, led by Nelly, had previously sabotaged the Buffalos' mascot, Mae. The quads open the gift anyway. Please by removing unnecessary details and making it more concise. Archived from on January 30, 2015. Dicky is the second one to fall in love with Mae when Mae bandages a cut on his finger. During the last invite, the butler asks the quads about Simone's new inventions.